Samir’s Selection 09/29/2015 (p.m.)

  • Gideon Rachman

    tags: China USpolitics UShistory ideology identity Asia history foreignpolicy

    • China and America have profoundly different ways of looking at the world. I see five big contrasts.
    • 1. Cyclical v linear:
    • ever since 1776, the US has basically only travelled in one direction — towards greater national power and personal prosperity. As a result, US politicians tend to think of history in a linear fashion and to believe in progress as the natural order.
    • 2. Universalism v particularism:
    • The Chinese, by contrast, are particularists. They believe that what is right for China is not necessarily right for the world, and vice versa. This difference in mentality underpins America and China’s contrasting approaches to intervention in foreign conflicts and the protection of human rights .
    • 3. Ideology v ethnicity:
    • The American state is built around the ideas embodied in the Declaration of Independence and the Constitution. Millions of people have become Americans by living in the US and embracing those ideas.
    • As a result, the Chinese and Americans tend to have rather different assumptions about crucial ideas such as nationhood, citizenship and immigration.
    • 4. Individual v community:
    • American leaders stress the rights of the individual. Chinese leaders stress the interests of the community. The difference between American individualism and Chinese communitarianism filters into their attitudes to the state. In the US, the ideas that the individual needs to be protected against an over-mighty state is built into the constitution and into political rhetoric. In China, it is more normal to argue that a strong state is the best guarantee against “chaos” that has led, in the past, to civil war and bloodshed. Many Americans assume that this Chinese rhetoric simply reflects the self-interest of the Communist party. But it also has deep historical roots. Americans might trace their emphasis on individual rights to the War of Independence in the 18th century. By contrast, in stressing the need for a strong state, Chinese leaders unselfconsciously refer to the “Warring States” period, which began in 476BC.
    • Different attitudes to the state lead to contrasting views of what holds a society together. Americans stress individual rights and the law. But while there is now much more talk in China of the need for strengthened “rule of law”, the Communist party is also promoting the Confucian tradition, which stresses a sense of hierarchy and obligation, as crucial to the smooth functioning of society. Once again, this has implications for international relations — since it affects China’s view of the proper relationship between big countries, such as China, and their smaller neighbours.
    • Rights v hierarchy:
    • The idea of the Middle Kingdom is rooted in China’s past. One historian describes it as “the extraordinary conviction of the Chinese people that their land is the centre of everything”. This conviction was shaken, a little, by the “century of humiliation” that began in the 1840s, when European and Japanese imperialists defeated China in battle. But a resurgent China is now sometimes accused of returning to a Middle Kingdom mentality, particularly in its treatment of the rest of Asia.


      The US, meanwhile, has become accustomed to its role as the world’s sole superpower. American foreign policy is still based on the belief that the US is the “indispensable power” in ensuring global order. American presidents, like Chinese emperors of old, are used to receiving extravagant tributes from foreigners.

    • The trouble is that while both countries may regard themselves as the “Middle Kingdom”, they cannot both be right.

Posted from Diigo. The rest of my favorite links are here.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s